An AI-generated Resident Evil Requiem review briefly made it on Metacritic

Engadget

by Ian Carlos Campbell

February 26, 2026

AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary

An AI-generated review of *Resident Evil Requiem*, published by UK gaming site VideoGamer under the pseudonym "Brian Merrygold," was briefly added to Metacritic before being removed. The review, identified as AI-written due to vague details and heavy use of contrived metaphors, raised suspicions furthered by Brian's profile picture, which appeared AI-generated with a filename revealing its origin. Metacritic, known for aggregating reviews to determine game scores, swiftly acted upon discovering the fake content. Marc Doyle, Metacritic’s co-founder, confirmed the removal of VideoGamer’s review and stated that any future AI-generated reviews would result in severing ties with the publication. The aggregator also informed other sites about its strict policy against including AI-written content. The incident highlights broader concerns about AI-generated content in media. VideoGamer’s parent company, ClickOut Media, shifted to AI-driven content after laying off staff earlier in 2026. This pivot underscores challenges in maintaining content authenticity and raises questions about the reliability of aggregated scores on platforms like Metacritic. For tech-savvy readers, this case emphasizes the need for vigilance in discerning between genuine and AI-created content online. As more platforms adopt AI tools to generate reviews and commentary, distinguishing between human and machine output becomes increasingly crucial for ensuring accurate information dissemination. This situation also prompts discussions on the ethical implications of AI in journalism and content creation. While AI can streamline processes, its misuse risks eroding trust in established review aggregators like Metacritic and raises questions about the future of credible online content. Readers are encouraged to remain cautious and critical when engaging with online reviews and commentary.

Verticals

techconsumer-tech

Originally published on Engadget on 2/26/2026