Are We Cruising Toward Cognitive Capitulation?
Psychology Today
by Cornelia C. Walther Ph.D.February 23, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
AI’s pervasive presence in daily life is reshaping how we think, potentially leading us toward a state of “cognitive surrender.” While artificial intelligence offers undeniable convenience and efficiency, research suggests it may be eroding our ability to reason independently. This shift isn’t just about relying on technology—it’s about fundamentally altering the way we process information and make decisions.
The traditional understanding of human cognition, as outlined in Daniel Kahneman’s *Thinking, Fast and Slow*, described two systems: System 1 (fast, instinctive) and System 2 (slow, deliberate). Now, some researchers propose a third system—AI itself, which acts as an external cognitive process. This “System 3” operates outside the human brain, functioning almost like a third mode of thought but with none of the limitations of human reasoning.
Experiments reveal that when given access to AI tools, people increasingly rely on them for decision-making, often without questioning the AI’s output. This trend goes beyond simple cognitive offloading (like using lists or reminders) and moves into outright cognitive surrender—the complete abdication of independent judgment. Younger users are particularly at risk, showing both greater dependence on AI and lower critical thinking skills.
The implications extend far beyond practical tasks. When we use AI to shape our beliefs or inform major life decisions, we’re ceding fundamental aspects of our identity and autonomy. This shift is especially concerning in areas like politics, morality, and ethics, where independent reasoning is crucial for maintaining personal agency.
Meanwhile, while humans risk losing their capacity for self-reflection, AI systems are being designed
Verticals
healthmental-health
Originally published on Psychology Today on 2/23/2026