Carly Pearce on Message of ‘Church Girl’: ‘I’m Not Condoning Reckless Behavior’

Rolling Stone

by Joseph Hudak

February 26, 2026

AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary

Carly Pearce’s new song “Church Girl” has sparked a divide among fans, with some applauding its honest exploration of faith struggles and others criticizing its portrayal of human vices alongside religious teachings. Written by Carter Faith, Cameron Bedell, and Seth Ennis, the track questions traditional notions of faith while emphasizing that flawed behavior doesn’t necessarily lead to damnation. Pearce clarifies that her intent is not to endorse reckless actions but to connect with listeners grappling with complex spiritual or personal issues. She shares how the song resonates with individuals like a 15-year-old questioning their identity or someone dealing with sexual purity trauma, reflecting her own experiences with societal expectations and her past marriage and divorce. Pearce’s approach challenges conventional narratives about faith and morality, offering a more nuanced perspective that acknowledges human imperfection. Despite facing backlash from fans who expected a Christian artist to uphold stricter moral guidelines, she remains committed to authenticity. Her song serves as a reminder of the universal struggles people face in navigating their beliefs and lives, making it relatable to a wide audience. The release of “Church Girl” highlights the growing cultural conversation around faith, morality, and personal freedom. By addressing these topics through music, Pearce contributes to a broader dialogue about how religion intersects with modern life. Her willingness to explore these themes not only reflects her own journey but also invites listeners to engage in introspection, making the song a significant cultural touchstone for those grappling with similar questions.

Verticals

cultureentertainment

Originally published on Rolling Stone on 2/26/2026