College football's most pivotal games for top 2026 Heisman Trophy contenders
CBS Sports
by
Cody Nagel
February 23, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
The 2026 Heisman Trophy race is poised to be one of the most competitive in recent memory, driven by a strong field of college football players. With an underwhelming quarterback class expected for the 2026 NFL Draft, top talent remains in college, making the competition fierce. Ten players, mostly quarterbacks, are listed on FanDuel Sportsbook with favorable odds to win the prestigious award next season. The race is further elevated by key head-to-head matchups that could determine the outcome.
Among these contenders, CJ Carr of Notre Dame (+800) faces a pivotal test against BYU in October. This game, while not the most high-profile on his schedule, is seen as crucial for Carr’s campaign. A strong performance here could propel him into national contention and set the tone for the rest of the season. Similarly, Ole Miss’ Trinidad Chambliss (+800) will have a defining moment in October when he faces Texas. This clash, against Arch Manning, comes during a critical stretch of SEC play that includes matchups with Georgia and LSU.
Texas’ Arch Manning (+950) aims to rebound from a lackluster debut last season against Ohio State. A rematch with the Buckeyes in September presents an opportunity for Manning to establish himself early in the race. Meanwhile, Indiana’s Josh Hoover (+1100) faces a significant challenge against Ohio State in October. This game, which could be his coming-out moment, is reminiscent of past Heisman hopefuls who made their mark against the Buckeyes.
Jeremiah Smith of Ohio State (+1300), the lone non-quarterback contender, will look to make an impact as a receiver. His pivotal game against Oregon in November could solidify his case if he delivers a standout performance. The race is not just about talent but also timing and narrative, with each player needing to seize their moment to stand out.
This season’s schedule is loaded with high-stakes matchups that could define the Heisman Trophy race. Readers interested in sports will find this season compelling as top-tier talent battles it out in key showdown
Verticals
sports
Originally published on CBS Sports on 2/23/2026