Controversial Women’s FA Cup plans on hold after pushback from clubs, players and fans

Guardian Sport

by Exclusive by Tom Garry

February 19, 2026

AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary

The Women’s FA Cup has hit pause on its controversial proposed changes after facing significant backlash from clubs, players, and fans. The Football Association (FA) initially planned to overhaul the tournament by seeding the top four WSL teams, eliminating draw ceremonies after the last 32 rounds, and introducing a "road to Wembley" bracket similar to a World Cup knockout format. However, these radical reforms have been halted due to concerns raised about fairness, tradition, and the impact on smaller clubs. The FA’s plans included reevaluating entry tiers for lower-league sides, which some argued could marginalize less prominent teams. The proposed changes also aimed to streamline the competition, with a focus on creating a more structured pathway to the final at Wembley Stadium. While the FA emphasized that these reforms were intended to enhance the tournament’s appeal and professionalism, they underestimated the resistance from key stakeholders. Feedback from clubs highlighted worries about disrupting the organic growth of the competition, which has historically allowed lower-tier teams to compete on equal footing with higher-ranked sides. Players and fan groups expressed concerns over the potential loss of unpredictability and the unique charm of the FA Cup format, which has been a staple of English football for decades. The FA has now paused its plans and extended the consultation period, acknowledging the importance of balancing innovation with tradition. This decision reflects a growing recognition of the tournament’s cultural significance and the need to preserve its grassroots appeal while addressing modern demands for competitiveness and inclusivity. For sports enthusiasts, this development underscores the delicate balance required in evolving women’s football competitions. The Women’s FA Cup’s role as a platform for all levels of talent is crucial, and any changes must align with both competitive integrity and fan engagement. By pausing its reforms, the FA signals a commitment to listening to stakeholders while ensuring the tournament remains a cherished event in the football calendar.

Verticals

sports

Originally published on Guardian Sport on 2/19/2026