Eileen Gu Is an Indictment of Birthright Citizenship | RealClearPolitics
RealClearPolitics
by Elle Purnell, The FederalistFebruary 22, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
Eileen Gu has become a focal point in the ongoing debate over birthright citizenship in the United States. The article argues that Gu’s story exemplifies the principles of America’s immigration orthodoxy, which emphasizes economic opportunity without requiring loyalty or cultural ties. Born in China but granted U.S. citizenship through her American parents, Gu’s journey highlights the complexities of citizenship in a globalized world. Critics suggest that this system prioritizes individual gain over collective identity, raising questions about what it truly means to be American.
The piece delves into the concept of birthright citizenship, which grants citizenship to anyone born on U.S. soil or its territories, regardless of their parents’ nationality. This policy, rooted in the 14th Amendment, has long been a cornerstone of American identity but is increasingly scrutinized. Gu’s case, as a successful athlete and businesswoman who identifies as Chinese, challenges traditional notions of loyalty and belonging. While some argue that birthright citizenship fosters inclusivity and opportunity, others contend it undermines national unity by creating individuals with divided loyalties.
The article also explores the broader implications of such debates in the context of globalization. It questions whether an immigration system that prioritizes economic gain over cultural integration is sustainable. Critics warn that this approach risks eroding national identity and fostering a sense of detachment among citizens who may feel disconnected from their country’s values and traditions. Proponents, however, argue that birthright citizenship reflects America’s status as a nation of immigrants and reinforces its reputation as a land of opportunity.
Ultimately, the discussion around Eileen Gu serves as a reminder of the evolving nature of American identity. As the country grapples with questions about immigration, citizenship, and national belonging, cases like hers spark important conversations about what it means to be an American
Verticals
politicsnews
Originally published on RealClearPolitics on 2/22/2026