Eileen Gu Is an Indictment of Birthright Citizenship | RealClearPolitics

RealClearPolitics

by Elle Purnell, The Federalist

February 22, 2026

AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary

Eileen Gu, a Chinese-American skier who won gold at the Beijing Olympics, has sparked a heated debate about birthright citizenship in the U.S. Born in California to parents from Taiwan, Gu competes for China but holds dual citizenship, raising questions about loyalty and national identity. Her story highlights the complexities of immigration policies, where individuals can benefit from multiple nations without deep ties to any, challenging traditional notions of belonging. Birthright citizenship, a cornerstone of American law since 1898, grants automatic citizenship to anyone born on U.S. soil. Proponents argue it ensures equal opportunity and unifies diverse communities. However, critics like Gu’s case point out potential issues: individuals might exploit the system for personal gain without reciprocating loyalty or cultural ties. This debate gained traction post-9/11, with concerns over security and resource allocation. Gu’s narrative underscores broader political tensions. Advocates of open borders laud her story as a testament to diversity and globalism. Yet, skeptics warn against the erosion of national identity and the potential for divided loyalties. Her success exemplifies both the opportunities and challenges of modern immigration policies, making her a microcosm of the larger debate over citizenship and belonging. Ultimately, Gu’s story matters because it forces policymakers to grapple with how to balance inclusivity with

Verticals

politicsnews

Originally published on RealClearPolitics on 2/22/2026