Fun with Algebraic Effects - from Toy Examples to Hardcaml Simulations
Hacker News
February 10, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
Porting the Hardcaml_step_testbench library from monads to algebraic effects in OCaml 5 has revealed a more elegant and powerful approach to handling computations, particularly for simulations. The article highlights how algebraic effects, a new feature in OCaml 5, offer a cleaner alternative to traditional monadic programming. By leveraging the Handled_effect library, developers can write code that is easier to read and maintain, avoiding the pitfalls of monads which often "infect" code and complicate interactions with libraries and functions.
The author explains that monads, while useful for modeling computations, can make code harder to understand by requiring special functions and syntactic sugar like let%bind. This leads to a loss of readability and flexibility, as all interacting code must adhere to the monad's structure. In contrast, algebraic effects provide a more straightforward way to handle asynchronous operations and simulations, allowing developers to use standard library functions without the overhead of monadic syntax.
The article also touches on how algebraic effects address limitations with unboxed types and local mode in OCaml, which are valuable features for optimizing performance. By eliminating the need for monad-specific constructs, algebraic effects enable a more natural and efficient style of programming, particularly for concurrent and simulation-based tasks.
For readers interested in tech and startups, this shift matters because it demonstrates how language features can evolve to meet the needs of modern software development. Algebraic effects show promise as a versatile tool for building scalable and maintainable systems, potentially influencing other libraries and projects to adopt similar approaches. This change not only improves code readability but also opens up new possibilities for leveraging OCaml's capabilities in demanding technical environments.
In summary, the move from monads to algebraic effects represents a significant step forward in programming language design, offering developers a more intuitive and efficient way to handle complex computations. The practical benefits of this approach—greater readability, flexibility, and performance—make it a valuable consideration for anyone working on large-scale simulations or concurrent systems.
Verticals
techstartups
Originally published on Hacker News on 2/10/2026