I Can Only Imagine 2 Review: Works to Give Its Hero a Crisis of Faith

Variety

by Owen Gleiberman

February 20, 2026

AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary

"I Can Only Imagine 2" delves into the life of Bart Millard (portrayed by John Michael Finley), exploring his journey as a Christian rock star grappling with new challenges. While the first film focused on overcoming childhood trauma and daddy issues, this sequel shifts its attention to family dynamics and personal struggles. The story centers on Bart’s strained relationship with his teenage son, Sam, who has type 1 diabetes. This condition adds emotional weight to their bond, as Sam resents Bart’s constant concern over his health, while Bart worries about the long-term impact of his son’s illness on his future. The film introduces a new layer of conflict when Bart struggles to write another hit song after the success of "I Can Only Imagine." This creative block mirrors Sam’s own struggles with identity and independence. The directors attempt to inject tension by having Sam join his father on tour, where he faces pressure from the team but also finds inspiration in his passion for music. However, the film falters in delivering impactful drama, as the conflicts between Bart and Sam feel underdeveloped and lack the urgency needed to resonate with audiences. While "I Can Only Imagine 2" aims to explore deeper themes of family, faith, and self-discovery, it often feels disjointed and lacks the emotional punch of its predecessor. The attempt to balance musical aspirations with personal struggles falls flat, leaving viewers wanting more from a story that could have delved further into the complexities of parenting and artistic ambition. For readers interested in entertainment and faith-based cinema, this film highlights the challenges of following up a successful movie while trying to maintain its core message of redemption. Despite its missteps, it offers a glimpse into the ongoing evolution of storytelling within the genre, blending personal struggles with musical elements that fans of the first film may appreciate.

Verticals

entertainmentfilm

Originally published on Variety on 2/20/2026