Joey, Sterlo, Sticky: Can Manly swerve rugby league’s age-old halfback curse?
Sydney Morning Herald
by Dan WalshFebruary 21, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
Replacing a generational halfback in rugby league is no easy feat, as highlighted by Manly’s transition from Daly Cherry-Evans to Jamal Fogarty. Cherry-Evans, a long-serving and highly respected player, has left a significant void at the club, but coach Anthony Seibold believes Fogarty brings unique strengths that align with their future goals. Unlike Cherry-Evans, who was known for his leadership and longevity, Fogarty offers a different skill set as a playmaker and organiser, which Seibold sees as a perfect fit for the team’s evolving needs.
The article explores the challenges of replacing a club icon, referencing examples from other teams like Canberra and Melbourne, where similar transitions have been difficult. Manly, however, is taking a deliberate approach, focusing on finding a player who can fill specific gaps in their game—namely, an organising halfback with a strong kicking ability. Fogarty’s experience and composure make him a suitable choice, even as he acknowledges his limitations compared to Cherry-Evans.
Seibold emphasizes that while the team will adapt to accommodate Fogarty’s style, key elements like speed and innovation remain intact. The coach believes the club’s attack will become more structured under Fogarty, but still retains its potential for excitement. With players like Tom Trbojevic expected to return soon, Manly aims to build consistency—a crucial factor in their quest for success.
This shift matters not just for Manly but also for rugby league fans worldwide, as it highlights the importance of adaptability and strategic planning in maintaining competitive teams. The club’s ability to evolve under Seibold’s leadership will be closely watched, especially given their recent struggles with consistency and forward depth. Whether Fogarty can replicate or redefine Cherry-Evans’ legacy remains to be seen, but his arrival marks a fresh chapter for the Sea Eagles—one that could set them on a path to sustained success.
Verticals
worldaustralia
Originally published on Sydney Morning Herald on 2/21/2026