Metacritic Removes Resident Evil Requiem Review From Website That Replaced Humans With AI
Kotaku
by Lewis ParkerFebruary 26, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
Metacritic has removed a review of *Resident Evil Requiem* from its website following an uproar over Videogamer, a gaming publication that replaced its entire human staff with AI-generated content. The controversy began when Videogamer revealed that all its reviews, articles, and other content would now be produced by artificial intelligence, sparking debates about the role of AI in journalism and entertainment criticism. This decision led to Metacritic, which aggregates game reviews, pulling the specific *Resident Evil Requiem* review from its platform as a response to concerns about the validity and ethics of AI-generated content.
The move by Videogamer to replace humans with AI for its reviews has been met with mixed reactions in the gaming community. While some see it as an innovative step forward in efficiency, others worry about the loss of human perspective and creativity in game criticism. The replacement of human writers raises questions about whether AI can effectively capture the nuances and emotions that human reviewers bring to their analyses.
This incident highlights a broader trend in the gaming industry and beyond: the increasing integration of AI into creative and critical spaces. While AI tools can streamline processes and reduce costs, they also challenge traditional notions of authorship and authenticity. The removal of the *Resident Evil Requiem* review by Metacritic underscores concerns about the reliability and ethical implications of AI-generated content, particularly in fields like journalism and entertainment where trust and credibility are paramount.
For readers interested in gaming and entertainment, this story matters because it touches on issues of quality, ethics, and innovation. The debate over AI's role in content creation is not just a technical or financial issue—it’s a cultural one that affects how we consume and engage with media. As AI becomes more prevalent, the question of whether human creativity and insight can be replicated—or should even be attempted—will continue to shape the future of journalism and entertainment criticism.
Verticals
gamingentertainment
Originally published on Kotaku on 2/26/2026