NCAA committee recommends stiff penalties for college football teams that try to circumvent transfer portal
CBS Sports
by
Robby Kalland
February 25, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
The NCAA Division I Football Bowl Subdivision Oversight Committee has recommended severe penalties for college football programs attempting to circumvent the new single transfer portal window. The proposed measures include suspending the head coach for six games, imposing a 20% fine on the program’s football budget, and reducing roster spots by five for the next season if an ineligible player participates in any athletically related activity at their new school. These penalties aim to address concerns about schools exploiting transfer rules by recruiting athletes who did not use the portal, potentially undermining the integrity of the system.
The single transfer portal window was designed to streamline the process and create a more structured timeline for student-athletes to transition between programs. However, its first year has been marked by challenges, with some schools reportedly attempting to bypass the system by having athletes withdraw from their current institutions and enroll elsewhere outside the designated period. The NCAA fears this practice could disrupt competitive balance and fairness in college football.
The proposed penalties are intended to deter such behavior by making it too costly for programs to violate transfer rules. By targeting the coach’s ability to recruit or coach, along with financial repercussions and roster limitations, the NCAA seeks to level the playing field and ensure compliance. This approach reflects a hardline stance against what the organization views as exploitation of the system.
Critics argue that these measures may face legal challenges, as they effectively penalize student-athletes’ rights to transfer by restricting their ability to play at their new institution until the NCAA’s rules are followed. The proposal highlights the ongoing tension between maintaining competitive balance and respecting athletes’ autonomy in choosing where to play.
Ultimately, this issue matters to sports fans because it impacts the fairness of college football competition. If adopted, these penalties could set a precedent for enforcing transfer rules more strictly, potentially reducing manipulation and ensuring that all programs operate within the same framework. The outcome of this proposal will likely shape how transfers are managed in the future and whether schools continue to find loopholes to gain competitive advantages.
Verticals
sports
Originally published on CBS Sports on 2/25/2026