Newsom's Struggle for Everyman Cred | RealClearPolitics

RealClearPolitics

by Ed Burmila, The New Republic

February 25, 2026

AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary

Gavin Newsom, California's governor, is currently grappling with a credibility crisis as he prepares for his re-election campaign. Critics argue that despite his image as a relatable leader, Newsom's policies and actions have increasingly diverged from the progressive rhetoric he once championed, particularly in areas like housing and homelessness. This disconnect has raised questions about whether he truly understands the struggles of everyday Californians, undermining his appeal to voters who expect their leaders to embody the values they espouse. The article highlights how Newsom's administration has faced significant backlash for policies perceived as out of touch. For instance, while Newsom previously criticized Proposition 65 rent control, his own housing initiatives have been accused of prioritizing market-driven solutions over tenant protections. This inconsistency has allowed opponents to question his authenticity and commitment to addressing the state's pressing issues. Additionally, Newsom's decision to reverse a ban on flavored tobacco products, despite earlier support for public health measures, has further eroded trust among progressives. This struggle for credibility matters deeply in the political landscape of California, where voters often demand transparency and alignment between rhetoric and action. For Newsom, maintaining his reputation as an Everyman leader is crucial for his re-election chances, but his current trajectory risks alienating key constituencies. The article underscores the importance of authenticity in leadership, particularly in a state with deep partisan divides and high stakes for policy outcomes. Ultimately, Newsom's ability to reconcile his image with his policies will determine whether he can regain public trust and secure another term. As the election season heats up, this issue will likely become a central battleground, reflecting broader concerns about governance, accountability, and the gap between political promises and reality.

Verticals

politicsnews

Originally published on RealClearPolitics on 2/25/2026