‘Paradise’ Review: Hulu’s Post-Apocalyptic Drama Gets Bigger but Not Better in a Messy Second Season

Hollywood Reporter

by Angie Han

February 22, 2026

AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary

Hulu’s post-apocalyptic drama *Paradise* continues to explore emotional depths with its second season, blending heartfelt moments with a sprawling narrative that often feels out of balance. Created by *This Is Us* mastermind Dan Fogelman, the series features an expansive cast, including Shailene Woodley and Sterling K. Brown, as it delves into the lives of survivors in a desolate world. While the show excels at evoking strong emotions—whether through moments of despair or camaraderie—it struggles to maintain a coherent plot amidst its ambitious scope. The first season anchored its story around a single location and mystery, which kept viewers engaged despite its flaws. The second season, however, expands its focus, scattering characters across vast distances and introducing numerous new ones. While this approach introduces fresh perspectives, such as Shailene Woodley’s portrayal of Annie, a survivor who finds solace in the remnants of Elvis Presley’s Graceland, it also leads to plot holes and unresolved subplots. For instance, the premiere episode, directed by Glenn Ficarra and John Requa, shines with its exploration of survival and isolation, but questions about realism—like the feasibility of a four-digit password or ID design—begin to surface. The season’s emotional high points, such as the bond between characters in a doomsday prepper group or the innocence lost among orphaned children, are powerful. However, the narrative sprawl leaves some storylines dangling, leaving viewers frustrated. Despite these inconsistencies, *Paradise* remains compelling due to its ability to evoke the haunting beauty of post-apocalyptic survival, reminiscent of HBO’s *The Last of Us*. For entertainment enthusiasts, this season highlights the fine line between emotional resonance and logical consistency in storytelling. While it may not always land perfectly, its ambition and emotional depth make it worth watching for those who appreciate a drama that pushes boundaries.

Verticals

entertainmentfilm

Originally published on Hollywood Reporter on 2/22/2026