Ranking the NFL's best players who haven't won a Super Bowl: Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson make the cut
CBS Sports
by
Bryan DeArdo
February 24, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
The NFL has its share of legendary players who have redefined their positions but have yet to hoist a Super Bowl Lombardi Trophy. Among them are Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, and Joe Burrow, all of whom have showcased extraordinary talent on the field. While Burrow came close in 2021, falling short against the Rams in Super Bowl LVI, Allen and Jackson remain undefeated in their quest for championship glory. This article ranks the top-30 NFL players in history who have not won a Super Bowl, highlighting their near-misses and enduring legacies.
Josh Allen, propelled by his MVP-caliber 2024 season, leads this list as one of the NFL's brightest stars. Despite back-to-back AFC Championship appearances with the Buffalo Bills, Allen has yet to reach the ultimate stage. In 2025, injuries and controversial calls derailed their playoff run, leaving Allen and the Bills searching for a breakthrough under new coach Joe Brady.
Lamar Jackson, another MVP-worthy quarterback, joins Allen on this list. Known for his dual-threat capabilities and unprecedented success with the Baltimore Ravens, Jackson has consistently elevated his game but hasn't quite reached the pinnacle of NFL success. His inclusion among only 11 players to win multiple MVP awards underscores his elite status despite lacking a Super Bowl ring.
Philip Rivers, another seasoned veteran, rounds out this trio. Despite leading the Chargers to within striking distance of victory in the 2007 AFC Championship Game, a valiant effort against an undefeated Patriots team ultimately fell short. His story exemplifies resilience and determination in the face of defeat.
This list not only honors players like Allen, Jackson, and Burrow but also pays tribute to football legends who came up just shy of greatness. For sports enthusiasts, these stories of near-victories and unfulfilled potential add depth to the narratives of NFL history, reminding us that success is often measured not just in wins, but in the courage to keep striving for it.
Verticals
sports
Originally published on CBS Sports on 2/24/2026