Sarah Pidgeon Learned to Speak Her Mind by Playing Style Icon Carolyn Bessette Kennedy in ‘Love Story’
Hollywood Reporter
by Lexi CarsonFebruary 14, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
Sarah Pidgeon earned a Tony nomination for *Stereophonic* and has appeared in films like *I Know What You Did Last Summer*, but her latest role as Carolyn Bessette Kennedy in Ryan Murphy’s FX series *Love Story* has thrust her into the spotlight. Playing the iconic style icon, who tragically died alongside John F. Kennedy Jr. in 1999, Pidgeon immersed herself in Carolyn’s signature minimalist aesthetic while navigating the challenges of portraying a beloved figure. She shared how advocating for herself during the project’s early criticism—such as adjusting Carolyn’s hair and wardrobe—helped her grow both as an actress and as a person.
Pidgeon’s journey to landing the role began with an audition tape that caught the attention of producers. Though she initially worried about her casting after seeing a photoshopped image of herself with blonde hair, it ultimately helped seal her place in the role. The series meticulously recreated Carolyn’s iconic outfits, including her famous Yohji Yamamoto pencil skirt and Manolo heels, which Pidgeon described as particularly challenging yet rewarding to pull off.
The story resonates not just for its nostalgic look at 90s fashion but also for its behind-the-scenes glimpse into Murphy’s creative process. Pidgeon praised Murphy’s support despite early backlash, highlighting the collaborative environment that allowed her to thrive. As she continues to build her career, mirroring Carolyn’s trajectory as a rising star, Pidgeon’s experience offers insight into the artistry and advocacy required to bring such a iconic figure to life. For entertainment fans, this is a compelling look at how personal growth intersects with public perception in the world of showbiz.
Verticals
entertainmentfilm
Originally published on Hollywood Reporter on 2/14/2026