The new Stranger Things character sticks out like a sore thumb
Creative Bloq
by Natalie Fear February 25, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
Netflix’s upcoming *Stranger Things: Tales from '85* has sparked mixed reactions among fans, largely due to its bold new character design. The animated spinoff, set between seasons 2 and 3 of the original series, introduces Nikki Baxter, a character whose look has divided audiences. While the show’s posters boast a striking, stylized aesthetic that pays homage to the '80s charm of the main cast, it’s Nikki who has become the focal point of criticism. Her mohawked, smug appearance has led many fans to label her as an unrelatable "self-insert" character, feeling out of place among the show's nostalgic vibe.
The design of *Tales from '85* aims to balance familiarity with fresh innovation. The posters feature dramatic lighting and bold color schemes that echo the original series but add a distinct animated flair. However, Nikki’s design stands apart, with her look being described as overly generic and lacking depth. Critics argue that her appearance disrupts the show's signature charm, which relies on its childlike, '80s-inspired characters.
Despite the backlash, there’s hope that *Tales from '85* could redeem the franchise. Fans are cautiously optimistic about the animated format, with many willing to overlook Nikki for the potential nostalgia factor. The show’s design choices, while polarizing, reflect Netflix’s strategy to milk the *Stranger Things* franchise as much as possible. Yet, the high expectations within the fandom mean that every creative decision will be closely scrutinized.
For readers interested in design and animation, this spinoff offers a fascinating case study in retro aesthetics and fan reception. The clash between modern animated styles and '80s nostalgia highlights how character design can either make or
Verticals
designart
Originally published on Creative Bloq on 2/25/2026