Way-too-early NFL QB hot seat rankings: J.J. McCarthy, Michael Penix Jr. among 5 facing make-or-break season
CBS Sports
by
Tyler Sullivan
February 20, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
The NFL is gearing up for another season, and five young quarterbacks face critical pressure in 2026 as they aim to prove themselves as franchise cornerstones or risk losing their starting jobs. With the 2025 season wrapping up, teams are evaluating whether their current signal-callers can lead them to success or if changes are needed. This uncertainty has created a high-stakes environment for these quarterbacks, who must deliver strong performances in the upcoming year to secure their futures.
C.J. Stroud of the Houston Texans is under intense scrutiny after a disappointing follow-up to his rookie season. Despite a standout 2023 campaign, Stroud’s performance regressed in 2024-2025, with declining completion rates and passer rating compared to his previous year. His four-interception game in the playoffs further raised doubts about his ability to lead Houston to sustained success. The Texans are weighing whether to extend his contract or hold off on a long-term deal, potentially leaving Stroud’s future uncertain if he doesn’t bounce back.
Bryce Young of the Carolina Panthers is also facing pressure after a career-high 2025 season. While he showed promise with improved passing yards and touchdowns, his overall numbers (63.6% completion rate, 188.2 yards per game) suggest room for growth. The Panthers are likely to pick up his fifth-year option but will be closely monitoring his progress in 2026. If Young falters or fails to build on his momentum, questions about his long-term viability as the team’s quarterback could intensify.
Michael Penix Jr., another key player on this list, is entering a pivotal year with the Jacksonville Jaguars. After inconsistent starts and benchings early in his career, Penix showed flashes of potential in 2025 but needs to demonstrate consistency. With the Jaguars looking for stability at the position, Penix must prove he can handle the mental and physical demands of leading an NFL team.
J.J. McCarthy, a rising star with the Detroit Lions, is also on the hot seat after showing promise during his rookie season but struggling to build momentum in 2025. His ability to perform under pressure and lead the Lions’ offense will be closely watched as he aims to solidify his role.
Zach Wilson of the New York Jets rounds out this list. Despite being a former No. 1 overall pick, Wilson has yet to establish himself as
Verticals
sports
Originally published on CBS Sports on 2/20/2026