What Will ‘Today’ Do if Savannah Guthrie Doesn’t Return?

Hollywood Reporter

by Anthony Maglio

February 21, 2026

AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary

Savannah Guthrie, a beloved co-anchor on NBC’s *Today* show, has been absent from her role since her mother, Nancy Guthrie, was kidnapped in Tucson, Arizona, on February 1. The incident has left the Guthrie family devastated, with no proof of life regarding Nancy, who is 84 and in poor health. While the show has continued to air with temporary replacements, including Sheinelle Jones, the situation has cast doubt over Savannah’s future return. Internal sources suggest that while executives hope she will eventually come back, there is growing speculation that her personal trauma may make it difficult for her to resume her role. The *Today* team has shown strong support for Savannah during this crisis, dedicating segments to Nancy and sharing updates from law enforcement. Despite extensive efforts by local authorities and the FBI, little progress has been made in solving the case, with officials warning it could take months or even years. This prolonged uncertainty has added to the emotional weight on Savannah and her family. Meanwhile, colleagues like Hoda Kotb have also contributed to the show during Savannah’s absence. The possibility of Savannah not returning has sparked rumors and speculation within entertainment circles. Sources close to NBC suggest that if she decides to leave the show permanently, the network is likely to promote from within, with Sheinelle Jones being seen as a strong candidate for the role. However, some industry veterans believe it is unlikely Savannah will ever return, citing her dedication to her family and the immense trauma she has endured. This situation not only highlights the challenges of balancing personal tragedy with professional responsibilities but also underscores the importance of support systems in high-pressure environments like network television. For entertainment enthusiasts, the unfolding drama surrounding Savannah Guthrie’s future on *Today* adds another layer of intrigue to an already gripping story.

Verticals

entertainmentfilm

Originally published on Hollywood Reporter on 2/21/2026