When Caring Becomes Counterculture
The Atlantic
February 25, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
When Caring Becomes Counterculture: A Deep Dive into Politics, Culture, and Resistance
The latest episode of *The David Frum Show* explores the intersection of politics, culture, and resistance, with Atlantic staff writer David Frum and Tim Miller of *The Bulwark* discussing topics ranging from President Trump’s reaction to a Supreme Court defeat on tariffs to the State of the Union address. The conversation highlights how younger generations are increasingly turned off by the “Resist libs” movement, which has fueled Trump’s politics through its perceived cynicism and overreach.
Frum argues that Trump’s frustration with the Supreme Court’s ruling on tariffs stems not just from economic losses but from the loss of unchecked power. Trump viewed tariffs as a tool of arbitrary authority, allowing him to bypass Congress and assert control over international trade policies. The Supreme Court’s decision stripped him of this perceived power, leaving him furious—and likely to double down on claims of unfair trade practices rather than seeking legislative solutions through Congress.
Miller shares his insights from visiting Minneapolis during ongoing ICE enforcement operations, shedding light on how younger Americans perceive the “Resist libs” movement as cringe-worthy and out of touch. This generational divide has fueled Trump’s politics by creating a sense of cultural alienation among his base. The episode also raises questions about whether Never Trump conservatives have drifted too far to the left, potentially undermining their ability to challenge Trump effectively.
Frum revisits the history and purpose of the State of the Union address, questioning its relevance in the Trump era. Traditionally a moment for unity and cooperation between branches of government, the ritual has become increasingly politicized under Trump’s presidency. Frum suggests that rethinking this tradition could be essential to restoring its original intent as a unifying force rather than a platform for division.
This episode is a must-listen for anyone interested in understanding the interplay between politics, culture, and resistance in modern American governance. It sheds light on how generational divides and power dynamics are shaping the political landscape—and why these issues matter more than ever in today’s polarized climate.
Verticals
politicsculture
Originally published on The Atlantic on 2/25/2026