Why We Can’t ‘Nudge’ Our Problems Away
The Atlantic
February 19, 2026
AI-Generated Deep Dive Summary
A new book challenges the idea that small behavioral changes can solve major societal problems, a concept popularized during the Obama era through "nudge" policies aimed at encouraging actions like recycling or voting. The article argues that industries have long promoted individual responsibility to avoid regulation, using tactics like ads blaming consumers for environmental issues or promoting personal carbon footprint calculations. Behavioral economists later repurposed these ideas to encourage positive behaviors, but critics now claim this approach shifts focus away from systemic solutions.
The book "It's on You" by George Loewenstein and Nick Chater highlights how relying on individual actions fails to address the root causes of problems like plastic waste or carbon emissions. For example, while encouraging recycling or flying economy might have minor benefits, they distract from more effective measures such as limiting single-use plastics or regulating industries that contribute to environmental harm. This approach erodes trust in institutions by making individuals feel responsible for issues beyond their control.
The article also critiques the rise of "nudge units" created by political leaders like Barack Obama and David Cameron, which focused on subtle psychological cues to influence behavior. While these efforts may have had minor success, they often ignored more impactful policy changes. This critique extends to broader trends in individualism, where personal choices are seen as a substitute for collective action, leaving people feeling betrayed by systems that fail to address deep social challenges.
Ultimately, the article warns that relying on individual responsibility to solve societal problems fosters nihilism and distrust in institutions, making people more susceptible to leaders offering simplistic or extreme solutions. The book serves as both a mea culpa from behavioral science pioneers and a call for renewed focus on systemic change over personal behavior. For readers interested in politics, this highlights the limitations of relying on individual actions to address complex societal issues, emphasizing the need for structural reforms rather than individual nudges.
In an era where political leaders often prioritize easy fixes over comprehensive solutions, the book underscores the importance of tackling problems at their source rather than shifting responsibility onto individuals. This perspective is particularly relevant in highly individualistic societies, where people may struggle to reconcile their personal concerns with systemic failures. By questioning the effectiveness and ethics of "nudge" policies, the book challenges readers to consider how collective action—and not just personal choices—can truly create meaningful change.
Verticals
politicsculture
Originally published on The Atlantic on 2/19/2026